Gooey, Cheesy, hand-crafted delicious

Our Menu

“So glad we found this place! I’ve been wanting a slice of NY pizza and this is the best I’ve had.” – Aisha G, via Google Reviews

Take a look at our ever-expanding, richly creative menu. We feature premium hand-tossed pizza and the freshest Kosher and Vegetarian ingredients. Give us a try. You’ll be glad you did. 

Appetizers

Specialty Pies

Calzones

Entrees

Wraps & Sandwiches

Salads

Desserts

Beverages

Appetizers

Fried Pickles $6.50
Sweet & Buttery Pickles Battered and fried with a hint of lemon
French Fries $5.00
Golden and crispy. Made fresh to order. Add Mozzarella/Cheddar Mix or Garlic/Parmesan to your fries for an additional $3.50
Garlic Knots $4.50
Hand-tied and seasoned with fresh garlic and Italian spices. Served with marinara sauce.  Add Mozzarella/Cheddar Mix to your knots for an additional $3.50
Brooklyn Nachos $7.00
Homemade yellow corn tortilla chips with our special homemade cheese sauce and jalapeños

SM$7.00
LG$12.00
Chips & Salsa $6.00
Corn tortilla chips and a side of housemade salsa


Specialty Pies

Coney Island Cheese
Traditional red sauce, special mozzarella cheese

SM$18.00
LG$26.00
House Slice$4.00
Park Slope White Pie
Classic White Pie: garlic infused olive oil, oregano, mozzarella, sliced tomato

SM$21.00
LG$31.00
House Slice$4.50
Crown Heights Veggie
Red sauce, mozzarella, mushrooms, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, & black olives

SM$21.00
LG$31.00
House Slice$5.50
Flatbush Fresh Garlic
Red sauce, mozzarella, tomatoes & fresh garlic

SM$20.00
LG$30.00
Boro Park BBQ 2.0
BBQ sauce & red pepper flakes, mushrooms, red onions, mozzarella and Cheddar, topped with imitation Bac’n Bits and fried onions...mmmmm

SM$23.00
LG$35.00
Williamsburg Greek
Red sauce, mozzarella, diced tomatoes, Kalamata olives & feta crumbles

SM$21.00
LG$31.00
Canarsie Pesto
Basil pesto sauce, mozzarella, sun dried tomatoes, red onion & mushrooms

SM$21.00
LG$31.00
Sheepshead Bay
Housemade red sauce, mozzarella, Kalamata olives, capers & roasted red peppers

SM$21.00
LG$31.00
Bensonhurst Sicilian
Sicilian pie, super thick & square, red sauce, and mozzarella. Small personal comes in 10” square or 5” square slices

SM$20.00
Slice$5.50


Standard Toppings
Anchovy | Bac’n Bits | Banana Pepper | Black Olive | Capers| Diced Tomato | Extra Sauce|  Fresh Garlic | Fried Onion| Green Olive| Green Pepper| Jalapeno| Kalamata Olive | Mushroom | Red Onion| Roasted Red Pepper | Pineapple| Sliced Tomato| Sun Dried Tomato

Slice$1.50
SM Pie$2.50
LG Pie$4.50


Premium Toppings
Faux Italian Sausage| Meatless Meatball| Tuna | Extra Mozzarella | Feta| Faux Pepperoni| Non-Dairy Cheese Substitute

Slice$2.00
SM Pie$4.00
LG Pie$6.00


Veggie Combo
Add our Veggie Combo to any Slice or Calzone: includes tomato, red onion, mushroom, green pepper and black olive

Slice$2.00
SM Pie$4.00
LG Pie$6.00


Atara's World Famous Calzones

The Mozzarella $18.00
Jumbo Calzone filled with mozzarella cheese. Served with marinara and more mozzarella or any topping for an additional charge.
Napoli $20.00
Giant Calzone filled with meatless meatballs, faux Italian sausage, mozzarella & pizza sauce inside
The Dairy Free $18.00
Add any topping for an additional charge
Veggie Combo Calzone $19.00
Our signature mix of veggies including sliced tomato, mushrooms, onions, and olives.


Entrees

Mexican Salmon Salad $18.00
Gluten Free battered salmon served on a bed of Romaine lettuce with diced tomatoes, cucumbers & red onion, served with nachos & a slice of lemon and salsa on the side. 
Tilapia Street Tacos $22.00
Open face yellow corn tortilla, fried tilapia, slices of red onion, radish, lemon, romaine, and sliced avocado. 3 per serving
Spicy Salmon Platter $24.00
Wild caught baked Salmon on a bed of shredded romaine lettuce, served with diced tomatoes, red onion, lemon, jalapeño, topped with chili flakes and a touch of mozzarella.
Fully Loaded Tacos $20.00
Beyond beef, red onion, green pepper, jalapeño, mushroom cooked together and served in our homemade tacos on a bed of lettuce and tomato, topped with our house salsa and mozzarella. 3 per serving
Fish & Chips - Tilapia $20.00
Thinly cut pieces of tilapia battered and fried with our house french fries and a side of tartar sauce.
Fish & Chips - Salmon $23.00
Wild-caught Alaskan salmon battered and fried with our house french fries and a side of tartar sauce.


Celebrity Wraps & Sandwiches

Jerry Seinfeld Wrap $13.00
7-Grain “Chicken” Tenders, Romain Lettuce, Diced Tomato & House-made Ranch in a Tortilla Wrap
Spike Lee TKO Wrap $13.00
Fresh Tomatoes, Kalamata Olives, Red Onions, Feta, oregano and our special family dressing
Rhea Perlman Tuna Sandwich $13.00
Fresh Tuna Salad, chopped lettuce, sliced tomato on a toasted Ciabatta Bun, seasoned with house vinaigrette
Mel Brooks Cheese Melt $13.00
Toasted Ciabatta Bun with house-made garlic butter, mozzarella and cheddar cheeses, toasted to perfection and served with a side of ranch.


Salads

Greek Salad $15.00
Fresh Roma tomatoes, cucumber, green peppers, feta cheese, kalamata olives & our special house vinaigrette dressing
Brooklyn Salad $15.00
Chopped lettuce, diced tomato, diced cucumber. Comes with our 7-grain “Chicken” strips OR substitute house-made tuna salad. Comes with choice of dressing


Desserts

Zeppole $4.00
Italian doughnuts – These are possibly the most delicious things in the world. Fresh dough fried in oil and served hot in a paper bag with powdered sugar.
BP Brownie Cookie $6.00
Fresh Baked in-store, these delicious desserts are Gluten-Free and Vegan, but you'd never know it because they taste so good! (Baked in a dairy oven)


Brooklyn Water tower

Fountain Soda $3.00
Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Dr. Pepper, Root Beer, Fruit Punch
Gold Peak Iced Tea $3.00
Unsweetened Iced Tea, Southern Style Sweet Tea, Raspberry Iced Tea, Lemonade
Bottled Drinks $3.50
Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Arrowhead Sports Water, Apple Juice, Orange Juice
Premium Bottled Drinks $4.00
Vitamin Water XXX, Vitamin Water Power-C, Gatorade Fruit Punch, Gatorade Cool Blue, Gatorade Lemon-Lime


No products in the cart.